On June 16, 1998, Christina McNeil was murdered in her home and found the next morning by her father, Barton McNeil, a former Illinois State University student. McNeil is now serving a 100-year sentence for the murder, but McNeil has maintained his innocence since first being accused. Now, 27 years later, McNeil faces his most recent denial for an appeal by the Illinois Supreme Court.
McNeil, who is currently serving time at the Graham Correctional Center, is disappointed in the denial ruling. Still, he refuses to give up on the case and is determined to bring his daughter’s killer to justice.
“In the last 25 years, my daughter’s cries for justice have been silenced. I am going to make sure that as many people as possible know the truth and get justice for Christina,” McNeil said.
McNeil is not alone in this appeal denial. An inmate accused of armed robbery and murder in 199, Jamie Snow, has also been denied by the Illinois Supreme Court. While Snow has announced plans to seek clemency going forward, McNeil has admittedly stated he has no plans to seek clemency.
“To receive clemency, a person has to admit to guilt and wrongdoing, which is something I will never do. I know I am innocent and refuse to admit to something I did not do,” McNeil said.
McNeil believes that his ex-girlfriend, Misook Nowlin, is guilty of killing his daughter. Nowlin, who has denied these claims since the case first opened, is currently serving a 55-year sentence for the murder of her mother-in-law, Linda Tyda.
Despite McNeil’s defense attorney entering DNA evidence and expert reports into evidence, a member of the 11th Judicial Circuit Court, Judge William Yoder, has ruled to deny this evidence being brought into the case.
Fellow judge, and longtime witness and member of the case, Judge James Knecht, who has served for over 50 years as a judge in the state of Illinois, wished not to speak heavily on the case. However, Knecht did comment on the appeal system.
“The appeals process exists so that every person can get their day in court and justice can be received,” Knecht said.
McNeil has yet to give up hope and plans to do whatever he can to finally earn his innocence in court. McNeil’s cousin, Chris Ross, plans to soon host an event at Heartland Community College to spread awareness about McNeil’s case and wrongful convictions occurring in our justice system.









